The European Commission announced plans to transfer cryptocurrency supervision from individual member states to ESMA, addressing fragmentation concerns as industry experts debate potential impacts on innovation and regulatory efficiency.
The European Commission announced a sweeping restructure of cryptocurrency regulation across its 27 member states. The proposal shifts supervisory powers from individual national regulators to the European Securities and Markets Authority.
This marks a fundamental change in how the EU manages digital asset companies operating within its borders. The move addresses fragmentation issues that emerged during early MiCA implementation.
The commission unveiled the proposal on December 4 as part of broader financial market integration measures. All Crypto-Asset Service Providers will now fall under ESMA's direct supervision rather than individual country regulators.
National authorities in France, Austria, and Italy had previously raised concerns about inconsistent MiCA enforcement across member states. These regulators specifically requested ESMA assume tighter control in September communications.
Fragmentation Forces Regulatory Consolidation
EU financial markets currently show significant fragmentation compared to other major economies. Stock exchange market capitalization reaches only 73% of EU GDP while the United States achieves 270%.
The European Commission identified this disparity as a barrier to competitiveness and cross-border operations. Financial institutions face varying requirements across different countries, creating operational challenges.
"EU financial markets remain significantly fragmented, small and lack competitiveness, missing out on potential economies of scale and efficiency gains," the commission stated in its announcement.
The proposal aims to eliminate discrepancies from differing supervisory approaches among member states. ESMA will gain direct supervisory competences over significant market infrastructures including trading venues, Central Counterparties, and Central Securities Depositories.
This centralized approach mirrors the United States Securities and Exchange Commission's regulatory model. However, ESMA traditionally focused on coordination rather than direct supervision.
The Markets in Crypto-Assets Regulation took full effect on December 30, 2024. The framework established uniform rules for crypto-asset issuers and service providers across the European Economic Area.
Industry Split on Centralization Benefits
Policy experts express divided opinions on ESMA's expanded jurisdiction. Some view the consolidation as essential for regulatory maturity while others warn of innovation risks.
Faustine Fleuret from decentralized lending protocol Morpho expressed concerns about resource demands. Centralizing authorization and supervision within ESMA requires substantial human and financial resources.
"[ESMA supervision] would likely slow down decision-making and innovation, particularly for newer players in crypto and fintech companies who rely on close collaboration with their domestic regulators," Fleuret explained to industry sources.
Fleuret suggested a balanced alternative involving stronger oversight powers for ESMA over national regulators. This approach would include abilities to suspend or revoke licenses without full centralization.
Dea Markova from Fireblocks offered contrasting perspectives on the regulatory shift. Centralizing control and standards could address pressing concerns related to licensing, cybersecurity, and custodial risks.
"At a principal level, we believe that more standard-setting and guidance is needed to address risks stemming from operational resilience of the custody function," Markova stated.
The success of centralized supervision depends heavily on implementation methods and resource allocation. ESMA must develop substantial capacity to handle direct oversight of crypto companies across all member states.
Companies currently authorized in one EU member state can passport licenses to operate across the entire bloc. This system allows seamless cross-border operations under existing MiCA provisions.
The transition period allows entities providing crypto-asset services under national laws before December 30, 2024, to continue operations until July 1, 2026. This grandfathering provision applies until authorization decisions occur under MiCA requirements.
The proposal requires negotiation and approval from the European Parliament and European Council. These interconnected components form a cohesive reform package for establishing a genuine single market across the investment chain.
The commission emphasized maintaining package unity as crucial for achieving financial market integration goals. Swift implementation of these measures aligns with broader competitiveness objectives outlined in the EU's strategic planning documents.
National competent authorities will shift from primary supervisors to supporting roles under the new structure. ESMA committed to ongoing cooperation with these authorities for effective enforcement of MiCA provisions.
The regulatory consolidation aims to create more consistent practices for authorizations and oversight. This standardization addresses concerns about varying levels of consumer protection during the transitional phase.
Cross-border crypto operations face challenges from disparate regulatory interpretations among member states. The centralized approach seeks to eliminate these inconsistencies and promote unified market standards.
Market infrastructure supervision under ESMA extends beyond cryptocurrency services. The proposal includes oversight of traditional financial market components alongside digital asset providers.
The European Commission positions this integration as essential for fortifying EU economic strength. Strategic priorities including competitiveness, digital transitions, defense, and security depend on deeper financial market integration.
Implementation timelines remain subject to legislative approval processes. The commission expressed dedication to collaborating with Parliament, member states, and stakeholders for swift measure adoption.
Key Takeaways:
- EU proposes shifting all crypto oversight from national regulators to ESMA under unified supervision framework
- Industry experts split between innovation concerns and benefits of standardized regulatory approach across Europe
- Changes require Parliamentary approval as part of broader financial market integration targeting competitiveness gaps
: #MiCA #ESMA #CryptoRegulation #EUPolicy #DigitalAssets
Stay updated on the latest cryptocurrency news on our homepage.
Explore more in Latest News Category.
Related reading:
Key Topics
Crypto New Live
admin@cryptonewslive.org
EU Shifts Crypto Oversight to ESMA Under MiCA
European Commission proposes transferring cryptocurrency supervision from national regulators to ESMA, sparking debate over innovation impact across 27 member