Economist Peter Schiff argues MicroStrategy's Bitcoin-focused strategy has destroyed shareholder value, with the company suffering a 47.5% decline that would rank it among the worst S&P 500 performers.
The ongoing debate over corporate Bitcoin adoption has intensified after economist Peter Schiff highlighted MicroStrategy's dramatic 47.5% decline in 2025, positioning it as one of the worst theoretical performers in the S&P 500 index.
According to Peter Schiff on X, MicroStrategy isn't included in the S&P 500, but if it were, its current year-to-date losses would rank it as the sixth worst-performing stock in the entire index. The economist directly challenged Michael Saylor's fundamental investment thesis.
Strategy isn't in the S&P 500. But if it were, its 47.5% decline in 2025 would make it the 6th worst-performing stock in the index.
Schiff pointed to Saylor's repeated claims that purchasing Bitcoin represents the optimal corporate strategy. MicroStrategy has built its entire business model around this premise, accumulating massive amounts of the cryptocurrency. However, the economist argues this approach has fundamentally failed shareholders.
Bitcoin Bet Backfires For Corporate Holders
WuBlockchain reported Schiff's analysis, emphasizing how the strategy has eroded shareholder wealth despite Saylor's bullish stance. The 47.5% decline represents billions in lost market capitalization for investors who believed in the Bitcoin-first corporate model.
Economist Peter Schiff tweeted that Strategy is not included in the S&P 500, but if it were, its 47.5% decline in 2025 would rank as the sixth worst-performing stock in the index.
The performance contrast is striking when compared to traditional S&P 500 components. Only five stocks in that benchmark index would have performed worse than MicroStrategy's theoretical placement. This comparison undermines the narrative that corporate Bitcoin accumulation creates superior shareholder returns.
Corporate Cryptocurrency Strategy Under Fire
Saylor has consistently advocated for companies to convert treasury reserves into Bitcoin, presenting it as inflation protection and value preservation. MicroStrategy transformed from a software company into what critics call a leveraged Bitcoin fund. The firm's stock price historically traded at premiums to its Bitcoin holdings.
The 2025 performance data suggests that model has collapsed. Investors who followed Saylor's advice experienced losses approaching 50%, while the broader Bitcoin market also faced significant headwinds. The disconnect between Saylor's optimistic predictions and actual results has prompted renewed scrutiny.
Schiff's critique extends beyond simple performance metrics. He argues the fundamental strategy of converting corporate assets into volatile cryptocurrencies inherently destroys value rather than creating it. The economist has maintained his skeptical stance on Bitcoin throughout multiple market cycles.
MicroStrategy's approach involved issuing debt to purchase additional Bitcoin, amplifying both potential gains and losses. This leverage magnified the downside when cryptocurrency prices declined. Traditional corporate treasury management prioritizes capital preservation over speculative bets.
The debate reflects broader questions about corporate responsibility and appropriate asset allocation strategies. While Saylor positioned Bitcoin purchases as visionary leadership, critics view it as reckless gambling with shareholder capital. The 47.5% decline provides ammunition for those questioning cryptocurrency's role in corporate balance sheets.
#Bitcoin #MicroStrategy #PeterSchiff #MichaelSaylor #CryptoLosses
3 Key Takeaways:
- MicroStrategy declined 47.5% in 2025, ranking among theoretical worst S&P 500 performers despite Bitcoin focus
- Peter Schiff challenges Saylor's claim that buying Bitcoin represents optimal corporate strategy for companies
- Corporate Bitcoin accumulation strategy under scrutiny as leveraged cryptocurrency bets amplify shareholder losses
Stay updated on the latest cryptocurrency news on our homepage.
Explore more in Bitcoin News Category.
Related reading:
Key Topics
Crypto New Live
admin@cryptonewslive.org
Schiff: Saylor's Bitcoin Bet Destroyed 47.5% Value
Peter Schiff claims MicroStrategy's Bitcoin strategy destroyed shareholder value with 47.5% losses, ranking among S&P 500's worst performers in 2025.